Insurance Comparisons
6 comparisons to help you pick the right one.
State Farm edges out Allstate for most policyholders thanks to significantly lower average premiums, higher customer satisfaction ratings, and a superior AM Best financial strength score.
GEICO edges out Progressive for most drivers thanks to lower average premiums, higher customer satisfaction ratings, and a stronger claims reputation — though Progressive remains the smarter pick for high-risk drivers and rideshare workers.
State Farm wins for most drivers due to lower average full-coverage rates, stronger claims satisfaction scores, and an unmatched local agent network — but Geico is the smarter pick for digitally savvy drivers, military members, and those with less-than-perfect credit.
USAA is the clear winner for eligible members, but GEICO is the best option for civilians who can't qualify.
State Farm edges out Lemonade for most people thanks to its unmatched coverage breadth, financial strength, and nationwide availability — but Lemonade is the smarter pick for budget-conscious renters who live in supported states.
State Farm edges out Liberty Mutual for most policyholders thanks to lower premiums, a superior AM Best rating, and stronger customer satisfaction scores.