Allstate Insurance vs State Farm Insurance
Allstate vs State Farm is one of the most searched insurance matchups in America — and for good reason. Both are household names, but the difference between Allstate and State Farm is more than just marketing slogans. Should you choose Allstate or State Farm? That depends on whether you care more about specialty coverage options or raw affordability. Allstate compared to State Farm shows a clear pricing gap that favors State Farm for most drivers, yet Allstate's unique add-ons keep it competitive for the right buyer. Which is better, Allstate or State Farm? Read on — the answer might surprise you.
Key Differences
| Aspect | Allstate Insurance | State Farm Insurance |
|---|---|---|
| Average Auto Premium (Annual) | ~$2,941/year | ~$2,204/year |
| Average Home Insurance (Monthly) | $143.92/month | $129/month |
| AM Best Financial Strength Rating | A+ (Superior) | A++ (Superior — highest possible) |
| J.D. Power Auto Claims Satisfaction | 691/1,000 (below average, 15th place) | 710/1,000 (above average, 6th place) |
| Specialty Coverage Options | Gap insurance, pay-per-mile, sound system, new car replacement, mechanical breakdown | No gap insurance; fewer specialty add-ons |
| Accident Forgiveness | Available to good drivers upon enrollment | Requires ~9 years as a customer to qualify |
| Market Share (U.S. Auto) | ~9% (4th largest) | ~16% (largest in the U.S.) |
| Online Policy Purchase | Full online quote and purchase available | Quote starts online; must call agent to finalize |
Pros & Cons
Allstate Insurance
Pros
- Wider variety of specialty add-ons including gap insurance, sound system coverage, and new car replacement
- Accident forgiveness available to good drivers without a lengthy waiting period
- More discount options than almost any competitor, including green home, new homebuyer, and responsible payer savings
- Pay-per-mile Milewise program for low-mileage drivers — a flexibility State Farm lacks
Cons
- Consistently higher average premiums than State Farm — roughly $737 more per year for auto coverage
- Below-average J.D. Power claims satisfaction scores in multiple recent studies
- Not writing new policies in California, Connecticut, or Florida for homeowners
State Farm Insurance
Pros
- Lower average auto premiums across nearly every driver profile — roughly $737/year cheaper than Allstate
- A++ (Superior) AM Best financial strength rating — the highest possible score
- Higher J.D. Power customer satisfaction scores for both auto claims and home insurance
- Largest auto insurer in the U.S. by market share, with a massive local agent network
Cons
- Cannot complete a full auto policy purchase online — must speak with an agent by phone
- Does not offer gap insurance or some specialty coverages available through Allstate
- Not writing new homeowners policies in California, Massachusetts, or Rhode Island
Allstate Insurance vs State Farm Insurance: Full Comparison
State Farm is the biggest auto insurer in America for a reason — and price is a big part of it. I'd estimate the average driver saves somewhere between $700 and $800 a year by going with State Farm over Allstate, and that's before factoring in bundling discounts. When you look at the State Farm vs Allstate numbers side by side, the pricing gap is hard to ignore.
That said, Allstate isn't just a worse version of State Farm. It's a different product targeting a different buyer. Drivers who want gap insurance, pay-per-mile coverage, or accident forgiveness without waiting nearly a decade will find Allstate more accommodating. The Drivewise telematics program also offers more flexibility than State Farm's Drive Safe & Save for certain profiles. If you drive very little or recently bought a new car and want it replaced (not just repaired) after a total loss, Allstate deserves a real look.
For homeowners, the comparison gets murkier. Allstate vs State Farm on home insurance depends heavily on location. Allstate tends to beat State Farm on premiums in some states like Illinois and Delaware, while State Farm is cheaper in Hawaii and Arizona. State Farm's default home policy also includes an automatic 20% buffer above your dwelling limit — a perk Allstate charges extra for. That's a meaningful structural difference that most people don't realize until they're filing a claim.
On customer experience, State Farm consistently leads. It scored above the national average in J.D. Power's 2025 U.S. Home Insurance Study; Allstate landed below average. In auto claims satisfaction, State Farm placed 6th while Allstate ranked 15th. These aren't close scores. From what I've seen across independent surveys, State Farm's agent network is a genuine differentiator — people trust that there's a human who knows their file.
Allstate compared to State Farm on financial stability also favors State Farm. The A++ AM Best rating is the highest achievable, and State Farm's 2025 earnings — including $111.6 billion in earned premium across its property and casualty affiliates — reflect genuine scale and solvency. Allstate holds a strong A+ from AM Best, which is still excellent, just not at the very top.
The verdict for most shoppers: get a State Farm quote first, then compare it against Allstate if you have a specific coverage need. For teen drivers especially, State Farm vs Allstate isn't even close — The Zebra found State Farm saves teens an average of $622 per year over Allstate. For drivers with poor credit, flip that calculus — Allstate occasionally quotes lower in those cases.
This comparison is researched and written with AI assistance. Specs, prices, and availability may change — verify details with the manufacturer or retailer before making a decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
For most drivers, State Farm is the stronger choice. It offers lower average premiums, higher J.D. Power satisfaction scores, and a superior AM Best financial strength rating of A++. Allstate is better in specific situations — particularly if you need gap insurance, want accident forgiveness sooner, or prefer a fully online purchase experience.
Choose State Farm if your top priorities are affordability and customer satisfaction — it wins on both counts for the majority of driver profiles. Choose Allstate if you're a low-mileage driver who wants pay-per-mile coverage, need gap insurance, or have poor credit (where Allstate can sometimes quote lower than State Farm).
The four biggest differences are: (1) Price — State Farm averages roughly $737/year less for auto coverage. (2) Specialty coverages — Allstate offers gap insurance and pay-per-mile; State Farm does not. (3) Claims satisfaction — State Farm ranks 6th vs. Allstate's 15th in J.D. Power's auto claims study. (4) Financial strength — State Farm holds an A++ from AM Best vs. Allstate's A+.
State Farm is cheaper in almost every scenario. Its average annual auto premium is around $2,204 compared to Allstate's $2,941. For home insurance, State Farm averages $129/month vs. Allstate's $143.92/month. The one exception is drivers with poor credit, where Allstate may quote lower in states that allow credit-based pricing.
Yes, both companies offer multi-policy discounts for bundling auto and home insurance. However, State Farm's bundled rate averages $2,853/year versus Allstate's $3,886/year — a difference of over $1,000 annually — making State Farm the far better deal for bundlers.
Get Started
Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.